CMA probes Secret Escapes and Bannatyne over drip pricing: what it means

The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has opened three new consumer protection investigations into how prices are shown to UK buyers online, naming the travel deals website Secret Escapes, the coach holiday operator Caledonian Travel and the gym chain Bannatyne Health Club. The regulator said on Wednesday 18 November 2026 that it is examining whether customers were shown the total price upfront, or whether mandatory charges were held back and added later in the buying process, a practice known as drip pricing.

The cases were formally opened on 17 November and announced the following morning, exactly one year after the CMA launched its first wave of investigations under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 (DMCCA). The CMA stressed that it has reached no conclusions about whether any of the three businesses has broken the law. But the announcement lands in the middle of the Black Friday trading period, and the regulator used it to repeat a warning to every business selling online: the price customers see first should be the price they pay.

In short

  • Three new cases: the CMA is investigating Secret Escapes, Caledonian Travel and Bannatyne Health Club over suspected drip pricing, opened on 17 November 2026.
  • What is alleged: holiday buyers may not have seen ATOL fees, local taxes, resort fees, single-person supplements or flight price changes upfront; gym joiners may not have seen joining and facility fees.
  • No finding yet: the CMA says it has reached no conclusions; evidence gathering runs to April 2027, when the next case update is due.
  • Real penalties exist: under the DMCCA the CMA can fine up to 10% of global turnover and order refunds; it has fined firms more than £12 million and secured about £2.3 million in refunds so far.
  • Wider message: 23 businesses have now faced cases since April 2025, and the CMA has told retailers that delivery and other mandatory fees must sit in the headline price this Christmas.

What has the CMA announced about Secret Escapes, Bannatyne and Caledonian Travel?

In a press release published at 11:00 GMT on 18 November, the CMA said it was “continuing its crackdown on misleading online pricing practices” with three investigations. It described drip pricing as the practice “where mandatory charges are separated from the headline price and added later in the buying process”. Separate case pages for each business were published on gov.uk at the same time, each showing an opening date of 17 November 2026.

The announcement was reported within the hour by the travel trade press. Travel Weekly reported that the regulator had “opened investigations into two more travel businesses over price transparency”, noting that Virgin Atlantic Holidays has been under investigation since August. Travel Gossip, the legal news service MLex and the Dow Jones service MarketWatch also carried the story on Wednesday.

The CMA framed the scale of the issue with three numbers. It cited ONS estimates that British residents made more than 58 million overseas holidays last year and Visit Britain data showing 103 million domestic visits. It also cited ukactive research finding that 11.5 million people belonged to a gym in 2024.

The quote from the regulator

Emma Cochrane, the CMA’s executive director for consumer protection, said: “People should be able to compare prices like-for-like when spending their cash, whether that’s planning a hard-earned holiday or picking the right gym membership. Whatever you’re buying, hidden fees should not push up the price.” She added that the investigations “will consider whether businesses were clear about prices from the get-go”, and that the CMA’s message to businesses is “simple: the price customers see upfront should be the price they pay”.

None of the three businesses had published a response to the investigations at the time of writing. The CMA said all parties under investigation will have the chance to respond to any concerns before any decision is reached.

What exactly is each business being investigated for?

The three cases share a theme, mandatory fees that may sit outside the headline price, but the details differ. The case pages on gov.uk are more specific than the press release, and they show that the CMA is looking at different parts of the buying journey in each case.

Secret Escapes: fees and moving component prices

Secret Escapes Limited, which trades as Secret Escapes, is a members-only travel deals website selling discounted hotel stays and package holidays. According to the CMA, the investigation covers “its presentation of mandatory fees such as resort fees, local taxes or ATOL protection fees”, and also “whether the prices presented for components such as flights and car hire may increase during the consumer booking process”.

The CMA says it is investigating whether these fees and price variations are included in the total price “from the beginning of the purchase process”, and, notably, “whether the consumer is provided with a total price at any point in the purchasing journey”. That second question goes further than a simple drip pricing check: it asks whether some buyers ever saw a single all-in figure at all.

Caledonian Travel: per person prices and supplements

Caledonian Leisure Ltd, trading as Caledonian Travel, sells coach tours and package holidays. The CMA said it is concerned about whether the business “shows the total price upfront, including mandatory fees such as single-person supplements and city taxes”. The case page adds that the investigation covers “its presentation of indicative (per person) pricing” and whether all mandatory fees are included in any total or indicative prices shown.

That focus on per person pricing matters for older and solo travellers, who are a large share of the coach holiday market. A single-person supplement is not optional for someone travelling alone; if it appears only late in the booking, the headline per person price is not the price that traveller will pay.

Bannatyne Health Club: joining and facility fees

The Bannatyne Group Limited, trading as Bannatyne Health Club, runs one of the UK’s best-known independent gym and spa chains. The CMA said it is concerned that “joining fees and charges to access facilities were added later in the purchasing process, rather than clearly shown to customers upfront”. The case page says the question is whether mandatory fees are included in the total price shown when consumers buy memberships.

The CMA has already resolved one gym case on similar facts. In October it fined Gold’s Gym (UK) Limited £45,000 and ordered refunds of about £9,000 for not giving the total price for memberships, including the joining fee, “in a clear and timely way”. That precedent gives a useful indication of how the regulator views gym joining fees, though every case turns on its own evidence.

Business Sector Fees or prices under scrutiny Case opened Next update
Secret Escapes Limited Online travel deals, package holidays Resort fees, local taxes, ATOL protection fees; flight and car hire prices that may rise during booking 17 Nov 2026 April 2027
Caledonian Leisure Ltd (Caledonian Travel) Coach tours and holidays Per person (indicative) pricing; single-person supplements; city taxes 17 Nov 2026 April 2027
The Bannatyne Group Limited (Bannatyne Health Club) Gym and health club memberships Joining fees; charges to access facilities 17 Nov 2026 April 2027

Source: CMA case pages and press release, 18 November 2026.

What is drip pricing and why is it now illegal in the UK?

Drip pricing is the practice of advertising a low headline price and then adding unavoidable charges as the customer moves through the checkout. The extras might be called booking fees, service fees, resort fees, admin charges or joining fees. What they have in common is that the buyer cannot avoid them, so the first price shown was never the real price.

The CMA has argued that this does two kinds of harm. Consumers may pay more than they expected, or give up comparing prices because the true figure only appears at the end. Competition also suffers, because a business that drips fees can look cheaper than an honest rival that shows its full price from the start.

Under the DMCCA, which brought the CMA’s new consumer powers into force in April 2025, an invitation to buy must show the total price including mandatory charges that the trader can reasonably calculate. The CMA has said in earlier releases that drip pricing “was banned” under the Act. Where a fee genuinely cannot be calculated in advance, the business must explain how it will be worked out, but that is a narrow exception rather than a loophole.

Optional extras are a separate rule

Mandatory fees must be in the headline price. Optional extras are different: a business can offer them, but it must get the customer’s express agreement before charging for them. Pre-ticked boxes are not allowed. The CMA fined Marks Electrical £720,000 in June and Appliances Direct £1.2 million in October partly over extras such as removal and installation services that customers were automatically opted into.

For online retailers, these two rules are the ones most likely to bite at the till. A delivery charge that every buyer must pay is a mandatory fee; a choice between standard and next-day delivery can be an option. The CMA spelled out where that line sits in its pre-Christmas letter, which we covered in our report on the CMA warning online shops that the first price must be the total.

How much power does the CMA have to punish businesses?

Before April 2025, the CMA had to go to court to enforce most consumer law. The DMCCA changed that. The regulator can now decide for itself whether consumer law has been broken, impose fines of up to 10% of a business’s global turnover, and order businesses to compensate affected customers.

The process has several stages. After gathering evidence, the CMA can issue a Provisional Infringement Notice (PIN) setting out its concerns, and the business can respond. A case can then end with a finding of unlawful conduct, remedies, undertakings or closure. Businesses that admit the conduct and agree not to appeal can settle, which can cut a penalty by up to 40%.

That settlement discount has been used in every fine announced so far. The AA, StubHub, Marks Electrical, Wayfair, Appliances Direct and Gold’s Gym all received the 40% reduction after admitting breaches. In practice, the model encourages businesses to change their checkout quickly and pay refunds rather than fight a long case.

What the timetable looks like

All three new case pages give the same timetable: an initial investigation running from November 2026 to April 2027, focused on “information and evidence gathering”, with the next case update due in April 2027. Earlier cases suggest that the full process from opening to fine can take five to eleven months when a business settles. The AA case opened on 17 November 2025 and closed with a fine on 15 April 2026; Wayfair’s opened on the same day and closed on 12 October 2026.

What has the CMA’s crackdown achieved so far?

The CMA used Wednesday’s announcement to mark one year since its first consumer protection drive under the new powers. It said it has launched cases against 23 businesses since the DMCCA regime started, resulting in customers receiving £2.3 million in refunds and “more than £12 million in fines”. In October it had put the refund figure at “nearly £2.4 million”; the CMA has not explained the small difference between the two statements.

The table below sets out the six fines that are published on the CMA’s own case pages. They add up to about £11.85 million; the CMA’s “more than £12 million” total suggests further amounts that are not itemised on the case pages we reviewed.

Business Practice found Fine (after 40% settlement discount) Refunds ordered Date
AA Driving School and BSM (Automobile Association Developments) Mandatory £3 booking fee not in upfront price; 80,000+ learners affected £4.2 million More than £760,000 (average about £9) 15 Apr 2026
StubHub UK (Ticketbis S.L.) Mandatory delivery and service fees added at final checkout stage £889,200 More than £590,000 to 50,000+ fans (average about £10) 23 Jun 2026
Marks Electrical Customers pre-selected into paid recycling and packaging services £720,000 About £600,000 (average £15) 18 Jun 2026
Wayfair False time-limited “Daily Deals” and “Flash Deals” £4.8 million None announced 12 Oct 2026
Appliances Direct (Buy It Direct) False countdown offers; automatic opt-in to paid extras £1.2 million About £432,000 12 Oct 2026
Gold’s Gym (UK) Membership joining fee not shown clearly and in time £45,000 About £9,000 29 Sep 2026

Source: CMA case pages and press releases, April to October 2026. Totals are shopappy calculations from published figures.

The Wayfair penalty, the largest so far alongside the AA’s, related to countdown timers that did not mean what they said. We looked at how that ruling shapes this year’s sales in our piece on early Black Friday sales and the UK rules on fake countdown deals.

Which cases are still open?

Several investigations from the past year remain live. The CMA’s case list shows that viagogo, opened in November 2025 over mandatory fees on ticket sales, is still ongoing. In August 2026 the regulator opened drip pricing cases against Trainline, Virgin Atlantic and RED Driving School, all of which had previously received advisory letters putting them on notice.

The August cases give a sense of the sums involved. For Trainline, the CMA said it had observed train booking fees ranging from £0.59 to £2.79 per transaction and a £1.50 fee on coach bookings. For RED Driving School, it cited booking and “digital” fees of £7 or more per booking. For Virgin Atlantic package holidays, it said resort fees and local taxes “can cost hundreds of pounds”. Next updates on all three are due in January 2027.

Ryanair is also under investigation, opened in June 2026, over what the CMA describes as a potentially unfair mandatory fee linked to parents sitting with their children. According to the case page, Ryanair has sought a judicial review of information notices issued by the CMA; the Administrative Court refused its application for interim relief on 10 August, and the proceedings remain ongoing.

Why are holiday sellers in particular under the spotlight?

Travel has become one of the CMA’s most active enforcement areas. With Secret Escapes and Caledonian Travel joining Virgin Atlantic Holidays, three package holiday sellers now face open drip pricing cases. Travel Weekly noted that the latest cases come a year after the CMA published price transparency guidance specifically for the travel industry.

The trade press has also reported that the CMA is signalling more to come. According to Travel Weekly, Jason Freeman, the CMA’s consumer law director, told the Abta Travel Regulations conference in London last week: “We have more cases in the pipeline. If you don’t follow our guidance, we take it as an indication of high culpability if we come to enforcement.”

The industry’s competitive dilemma

Earlier on Wednesday, before the announcement, Travel Weekly published comments from Martin Alcock, director of Travel Trade Consultancy, who told a Travelzoo breakfast that some travel companies were still not fully complying because they feared looking uncompetitive. He said that including a daily resort fee for every member of a party “can be hundreds or thousands of pounds’ difference in price”, and that if competitors are not doing the same, “you look way too pricey”.

Alcock described a strategy of being “in the middle of the pack”, including most costs but “not totally everything”, and called it “a risky strategy”. That candid account goes to the heart of the CMA’s argument: drip pricing distorts competition because the business that hides fees appears cheaper than the one that does not. Enforcement is meant to remove the incentive by making the honest headline price the only legal one.

ATOL fees, resort fees and city taxes explained

The fees named in the Secret Escapes and Caledonian cases are familiar to anyone who has booked a holiday. The ATOL protection contribution is a charge collected on protected flight-inclusive holidays to fund the scheme that refunds or repatriates travellers if a firm fails. Resort fees are daily charges some hotels levy for facilities such as pools or Wi-Fi. City or tourist taxes are set by local authorities in many European cities and are often paid per person per night.

The question for the CMA is not whether these charges are legitimate, but whether they were unavoidable and therefore belonged in the first price shown. Travel Weekly separately reported this month that the Civil Aviation Authority is consulting on raising most of its charges by 6.1% in 2027-28, including targeted increases for ATOL holders, which shows that some of these underlying costs are themselves moving.

What does this mean for online retailers this Christmas?

None of the three new cases involves a retailer selling goods, but the rules being tested are exactly the ones that apply to every UK online shop. In its press release, the CMA reminded businesses that it published an open letter to retailers ahead of the Christmas shopping period “about the importance of ensuring that they make prices, including delivery fees, clear to customers up front”. It also pointed businesses to its “3 Step Pricing Check”, a self-assessment tool for spotting unlawful pricing practices.

The timing is deliberate. The busiest online trading weeks of the year are under way, with Amazon’s sale event running from 19 to 30 November, as set out in our guide to Amazon UK’s Black Friday Week dates, and most large retailers running their own promotions alongside it. A delivery charge, card surcharge or service fee that appears only at the final checkout step is the retail equivalent of a resort fee.

A practical checklist for UK sellers

  • Headline price: make sure every price shown on product and listing pages includes all mandatory charges you can calculate, including VAT.
  • Delivery: if every buyer must pay a delivery fee, it must be clear upfront; if delivery varies by option or postcode, explain how it is calculated before the checkout.
  • Extras: never pre-tick paid add-ons such as installation, removal, insurance or gift wrap.
  • Offers: countdown timers and “today only” claims must be true; extending a “final day” sale can breach the law.
  • Records: keep screenshots of checkout journeys and price displays, which help if a regulator or Trading Standards asks questions.

The direction of travel across UK and European regulators is towards all-in pricing at every step of the checkout, a trend we tracked earlier this year in our analysis of why all-in checkout pricing is spreading across UK and EU retail. Smaller sellers should not assume they are too small to be noticed: Gold’s Gym’s £45,000 fine shows the CMA will act against modest businesses as well as household names.

How does the UK’s approach compare with other consumer rules?

The drip pricing rules sit inside a broader package of consumer law reforms that is changing how UK businesses sell online. The table below sets out the main strands that affect online shoppers and sellers, and the body responsible for each.

Rule What it requires Who enforces Status
Drip pricing (DMCCA) Total price including calculable mandatory fees shown upfront CMA directly; Trading Standards via courts In force since April 2025
Pre-ticked extras Express consent before charging for optional add-ons CMA; Trading Standards In force; fines issued June and October 2026
Fake urgency and countdown offers Time-limited claims must be true CMA; Trading Standards In force; Wayfair and Appliances Direct fined October 2026
Fake reviews Ban on fake or concealed incentivised reviews CMA In force since April 2025
Subscription contracts Clear pre-contract information, reminders and easy cancellation CMA; Trading Standards Not yet in force

Source: CMA guidance and press releases; shopappy summary.

The subscription rules are especially relevant to gym memberships, which typically renew monthly. When they take effect, gyms will face separate duties on reminders and cancellation on top of the drip pricing rules now being tested in the Bannatyne case. We set out the detail in our report on the UK subscription rules and the right to cancel online.

The cost of living backdrop

The CMA has consistently framed drip pricing enforcement as part of its cost of living work. Official figures published on the same morning showed consumer price inflation rising to 3.6% in October, with household budgets under pressure ahead of an expected rise in energy bills in January. In that context, a few pounds of hidden fees on a gym membership or a few hundred pounds of resort fees on a family holiday are exactly the kind of charge the regulator says households should be able to see before they commit.

What can UK shoppers do if they were hit by hidden fees?

Consumers who booked with any of the three businesses do not need to take action now. The CMA has not found that any law has been broken, and refunds can only be ordered if an infringement is established or agreed in a settlement. In previous cases where refunds were ordered, the businesses contacted affected customers directly and paid money back automatically to the original card.

Shoppers who believe they were caught out by unexpected mandatory charges, with any business, have several routes. The first is to complain to the business and ask for the fee to be refunded, pointing to the requirement that mandatory charges are included in the upfront price. If that fails, consumers in England and Wales can contact the Citizens Advice consumer helpline, which passes intelligence to Trading Standards; Advice Direct Scotland and Consumerline in Northern Ireland play the same role.

Card protection and package holiday rights

Where a purchase was made by credit card and cost between £100 and £30,000, Section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 can make the card provider jointly liable for a breach of contract or misrepresentation. Debit card holders may be able to ask their bank for a chargeback, although that is a card scheme rule rather than a legal right and usually has time limits.

Package holiday buyers also have specific protection under the Package Travel and Linked Travel Arrangements Regulations 2018. A price can only be increased after booking if the contract expressly allows it and only for set reasons, such as fuel costs, taxes or exchange rates. If the increase is more than 8% of the total price, the traveller can cancel and get a full refund.

Situation First step Escalation
Unexpected mandatory fee at checkout, not yet paid Abandon the purchase and compare the total price elsewhere Report to Citizens Advice, Advice Direct Scotland or Consumerline
Fee paid by credit card (£100–£30,000 purchase) Complain to the business in writing Section 75 claim with the card provider
Fee paid by debit card Complain to the business in writing Ask the bank about a chargeback
Package holiday price raised after booking Check the contract terms and the reason given Cancel for a full refund if the rise exceeds 8%
Gym joining fee not shown when you signed up Ask the gym to refund the fee Report to consumer advice services; keep evidence of the sign-up page

What happens next?

The immediate next step is evidence gathering. The CMA said it will “engage with” each business and gather evidence to decide whether it believes consumer law has been infringed. The case pages say the next update is due in April 2027. If the CMA forms a provisional view that the law was broken, it will issue a Provisional Infringement Notice, and the business can respond before any final decision.

Any of the three businesses could also choose to settle by admitting the conduct, which, as in the six fines so far, would bring a reduction of up to 40% in any penalty. Settlement typically comes with an obligation to refund affected customers and to report back to the CMA on the refund process.

Beyond these cases, the regulator has made clear the crackdown is not slowing. Its press release said businesses “across all sectors” must review their practices or risk action, and Travel Weekly’s account of the Abta conference suggests further travel cases are already being prepared. Updates on the Trainline, Virgin Atlantic and RED Driving School cases are due in January 2027, and the Ryanair case is scheduled for an update in December 2026.

Key dates to watch

  • Late November 2026: Black Friday and Cyber Monday trading, the first big test of the CMA’s pre-Christmas delivery fee letter.
  • December 2026: next scheduled update on the Ryanair investigation.
  • January 2027: next updates on Trainline, Virgin Atlantic and RED Driving School.
  • April 2027: next updates on Secret Escapes, Caledonian Travel and Bannatyne Health Club.

The official case pages and the full press release are available from the CMA’s announcement on gov.uk.

Frequently asked questions

Which companies is the CMA investigating for drip pricing?

The three new cases announced on 18 November 2026 are against Secret Escapes Limited, Caledonian Leisure Ltd (trading as Caledonian Travel) and The Bannatyne Group Limited (trading as Bannatyne Health Club). Other open drip pricing cases include Trainline, Virgin Atlantic, RED Driving School and viagogo.

Has Secret Escapes broken the law?

No finding has been made. The CMA says it has reached no conclusions in any of the three investigations, and it should not be assumed that any business has infringed consumer law at this stage.

What is drip pricing?

Drip pricing is when a business shows a low headline price and adds unavoidable charges, such as booking, service, resort or joining fees, later in the buying process. Under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, mandatory fees that can be calculated must be included in the upfront total price.

How big can a CMA fine be?

Under its DMCCA powers, which took effect in April 2025, the CMA can fine a business up to 10% of its global turnover for breaking consumer law. It can also order compensation for affected customers. Businesses that admit the breach and settle can receive a discount of up to 40% on the penalty.

Will Bannatyne members get a refund?

Not at this stage. Refunds can only be ordered or agreed if the CMA finds, or the business admits, that the law was broken. In the earlier Gold’s Gym case, the business was ordered to refund joining fees and contacted affected customers directly.

Are resort fees and city taxes allowed?

Yes, the charges themselves can be legitimate. The issue the CMA is examining is whether, when they are mandatory, they were included in the first total price shown to the customer rather than added later in the booking.

Do the drip pricing rules apply to online shops?

Yes. The same rules cover any business selling to UK consumers, including online retailers. Mandatory delivery charges and other unavoidable fees must be shown upfront, and the CMA wrote to retailers before Christmas 2026 to remind them of this.

When will the CMA decide these cases?

The case pages show an initial investigation running from November 2026 to April 2027, with the next update due in April 2027. Past settled cases have taken roughly five to eleven months from opening to a fine.

How do I report a business for hidden fees?

Complain to the business first. You can then contact the Citizens Advice consumer helpline in England and Wales, Advice Direct Scotland or Consumerline in Northern Ireland, which share information with Trading Standards. The CMA also accepts information from the public about suspected breaches.