Christmas dupes go mainstream: Quince UK, Aldi candles and your rights

In short

  • Christmas dupes have gone mainstream: the Guardian reported on 15 November that cut-price versions of luxury candles, perfume and cashmere are among this season’s most talked-about gifts, with shoppers of every age now buying them.
  • Quince is the new name: the San Francisco online retailer, valued at $10.1bn (about £7.6bn), launched a UK site in October with £50 cashmere jumpers and product pages that compare its prices with Whistles, Cos and Reiss.
  • Aldi remains the high street dupe leader: its £24.99 XXL Inclusion Candle sits against a £95 White Company candle, and its £7 Lacura perfumes are pitched by TikTok creators as alternatives to designer scents.
  • Dupes are legal until they copy too closely: UK brands have won cases over lookalike packaging and product design, and a dupe that uses another brand’s trade mark becomes a counterfeit.
  • Your rights do not shrink with the price: a £15 dupe must still be of satisfactory quality and as described, and online orders carry a 14-day cancellation right on top of any retailer policy, including Quince’s 365-day returns.

Dupes, the cheaper products designed to give a similar look, scent or feel to a luxury item without claiming to be it, have become one of the defining shopping trends of Christmas 2026 in the UK. A Guardian report published on Sunday 15 November traced how the habit has moved from a Gen Z social media pastime to a mainstream way of buying gifts at a time of stretched household budgets.

The report singled out two retailers. Aldi, which has sold lookalike candles, beauty and homeware for years, and Quince, an American online retailer that launched in the UK in October and openly sets its prices against well-known British fashion names. This article sets out what has changed, how the prices compare, where the legal line sits and what shoppers can do if a dupe disappoints.

What did the Guardian report about Christmas dupes?

The Guardian’s piece opens with a festive candle. The White Company’s £95 “winter indulgence” candle, which customers describe as the “scent of Christmas”, has an Aldi equivalent that TikTok users recommend at £25. The newspaper describes dupes as products that “claim to offer a similar experience to a high-end item though do not claim to be that product”.

Catherine Shuttleworth, chief executive of the retail consultancy Savvy Marketing, told the Guardian that the appeal now cuts across age and income. “No matter what age you are, how much money you’ve got to spend, everyone wants to ‘luxe it up’ with a dupe,” she said, adding that a high street version of a luxury candle “can look and smell just as good as the real thing”.

The numbers behind the trend

The report draws on several data sources. The youth research firm YPulse found that 44% of UK 13 to 39-year-olds had bought a dupe in the past year, and that 53% of the same age group agreed that the quality of dupe or fake luxury items made them less likely to want to buy the real thing. NielsenIQ’s Eric Mills said that in a recent survey 38% of UK consumers had switched to lower-priced brands over the past 12 months to manage their shopping bills.

Mills also told the Guardian that the number of people buying dupe fragrances online had risen 17% over the past year, ahead of the overall fragrance market. TikTok says more than 30 million people in the UK use the platform each month, and the newspaper counted more than 50,000 videos under the combined hashtags #perfumedupe and #perfumedupes.

Who is actually buying

The assumption that dupes are a teenage fad does not hold up, according to NielsenIQ. “While Gen Z are key spenders, it’s millennials who account for the greatest proportion of sales,” Mills told the Guardian. Savvy Marketing’s own polling, cited in the same report, found that nearly 80% of shoppers were happy to spend more selectively on treats and luxuries they think are worth it, which suggests that many households now mix dupes with the occasional genuine article rather than switching entirely.

Who is Quince and what has it launched in the UK?

Quince was founded in San Francisco in 2019 and describes itself as a “manufacturer-to-consumer” platform. Retail Week and the Financial Times reported its UK entry on 18 October, and TheIndustry.fashion said the UK site went live on 19 October with womenswear, menswear, children’s clothing and homeware. Retail Gazette described it as a “$10bn US ‘dupe’ retailer”, although Quince itself prefers the phrase “affordable luxury”.

The UK is the company’s first market outside North America. According to TheIndustry.fashion, the expansion is backed by a $500m (about £378m) Series E funding round announced in March and led by ICONIQ, which valued Quince at $10.1bn (about £7.6bn at Friday’s rate of roughly 0.756 pounds per dollar). The company said at the time that it had generated more than $1bn (about £756m) in revenue in the previous year and had grown at triple-digit rates every year since launch.

How the pricing model works

Quince says it works directly with specialist factories and ships from the factory to the customer, cutting out sourcing agents, warehousing, wholesale, distribution and shop costs. It claims this lets it price cashmere, linen and leather 50% to 70% below comparable products. It also says it forecasts demand weekly by product and size, starting with small test batches, so it carries no seasonal overstock and holds prices all year rather than running markdowns.

Product pages on the UK site publish what Quince calls illustrative cost models. TheIndustry.fashion reported one breakdown totalling £24.99, made up of £10.77 for materials, £6.36 for making the item, 11p for packaging, £4.28 for freight and handling, £1.40 for card fees and £2.07 for duties, taxes and fees. Quince has said it has no plans to open physical shops because they would undermine that pricing structure.

The “traditional retail” comparison

The feature that has drawn most attention is the comparison price shown beside each product. TheIndustry.fashion reported that a women’s Mongolian cashmere funnel neck jumper was listed at £100 against £199 for a comparable item at Whistles, presented as a 49% saving, and that a men’s organic cotton slub crewneck T-shirt was priced at £20 against £69 at Nudie Jeans. The Guardian described a £50 red cashmere jumper pictured beside jumpers from Cos and Reiss costing three times as much.

Quince’s UK site carries a disclaimer alongside its cost graphics. It says traditional retailer costs “are an approximation based on our knowledge of what it costs Quince to produce this product” and “do not represent pound-for-pound costs of any specific third party”. Shoppers should treat the named comparisons as Quince’s own claims about similar products, not as an independent test of equivalence.

The Christmas push

On 9 November Quince launched its first celebrity-led campaign, a 60-second film called The Red Sweater starring the actor David Schwimmer, Retail Times reported. The campaign introduced a “Coulis Red” shade across its Mongolian cashmere range, with a women’s oversized crewneck at £110 and a men’s crewneck at £60, and paid media running in the UK, the US and Canada. Antonieta Moreland, Quince’s vice president of brand, said the business “started with a $50 cashmere sweater and a simple belief: everyone deserves access to exceptional quality”.

How do dupe prices compare with the originals?

The price gaps quoted this season are large, which explains much of the appeal. The table below brings together the comparisons reported by the Guardian, TheIndustry.fashion and Newsquest’s coverage of Aldi’s candle range. The “original” prices are those cited in those reports and may differ by size, edition or date.

Dupe Dupe price Compared with Quoted price Gap
Aldi XXL Inclusion Candle (4.5kg) £24.99 The White Company winter candle £95 About £70
Quince women’s cashmere funnel neck £100 Comparable Whistles jumper £199 49% (Quince figure)
Quince men’s organic cotton T-shirt £20 Comparable Nudie Jeans T-shirt £69 69% (Quince figure)
Zara Violet Blossom perfume £15.99 Mugler Alien Nearly £130 About £114
M&S Aura Ambrette perfume £22.50 Le Labo Another 13 Not stated n/a
Aldi Lacura perfumes £7 Paradoxe, Flowerbomb, Baccarat Rouge 540 Not stated n/a

Two points stand out. First, the biggest pound savings are on home fragrance and perfume, where the cost of the liquid or wax is a small part of the luxury price. Second, several of the comparisons come from creators or from the dupe seller itself, so the claimed equivalence is a marketing judgement rather than a tested fact.

Aldi’s candle range in detail

Aldi’s Inclusion Candles returned to stores nationwide on Sunday 1 November, according to a Newsquest report. The range comes in Winter Spice and Scandinavian Forest scents with dried fruit, berries and cinnamon sticks set into the wax. The XXL version weighs 4.5kg with a claimed burn time of 200 hours, a rectangle candle costs £12.99, and a small 660g candle costs £5.99 with up to 60 hours of burn time. Aldi says the range offers savings of up to 83% against selected White Company candles, and the products are sold in stores only while stocks last.

Why are dupes booming this Christmas?

The first driver is money. Household budgets have been squeezed by several years of high food and energy prices, and NielsenIQ’s finding that 38% of UK consumers have traded down to cheaper brands shows how far the habit has spread beyond the weekly shop. Gifts are an obvious place to economise because the buyer wants the look of a premium present without the premium bill.

The second driver is social media. Dupe content is tailor-made for short videos, where a creator sets a £7 bottle beside a £100-plus original and asks viewers to compare. shopappy has previously looked at how dupe culture changed value shopping earlier this year, and the Christmas wave suggests that the behaviour has hardened into a seasonal buying pattern.

The status of saving

Tori D’Amico of YPulse told the Guardian that “dupes are not shameful or embarrassing to own” and that young consumers “brag online about finding a good deal”. That shift matters for retailers. Where cheaper versions were once bought quietly, the find itself has become the status symbol, which turns every shopper into a potential advertiser for the dupe.

AI shopping assistants

NielsenIQ’s Mills also pointed to a newer factor. “It’s easy to imagine dupes gaining further traction, as consumers can simply ask a chatbot for a cheaper alternative to their favourite luxury scent,” he told the Guardian. As retailers and platforms add AI assistants to their apps, a request for “something like” a named product becomes a one-line query rather than an evening of browsing.

Is buying or selling a dupe legal in the UK?

For shoppers, buying a dupe is lawful. Dupes sit in a grey area between the authentic product and a fake, but the legal test is applied to the seller, not the buyer, and it turns on how closely the product imitates the original’s protected features.

Dupe, lookalike or counterfeit

A dupe offers a similar experience under its own name, such as a candle with a similar scent profile or a jumper in a similar yarn and cut. A lookalike copies the packaging or “get-up” closely enough that a shopper might assume a connection with the original brand. A counterfeit uses the original brand’s trade mark, or something nearly identical, and pretends to be the genuine product.

Counterfeits are a criminal matter under the Trade Marks Act 1994 for those who make or sell them, and they carry real safety risks: Trading Standards testing has found mercury and lead in fake beauty products sold to UK consumers. Dupes and lookalikes are handled through civil law, where a brand owner can sue for trade mark infringement, passing off, design right infringement or copyright infringement.

What brands can sue over

Brand owners have several tools. A registered trade mark protects names, logos and sometimes shapes. Passing off protects the goodwill in a product’s overall appearance where shoppers are likely to be misled. Registered and unregistered design rights protect the shape and appearance of a product, and copyright can protect artwork such as a palette pattern or a printed design.

Claire Breheny, partner and head of trade marks at the law firm Mathys & Squire, told the Guardian that brand owners “need to protect their packaging and get-up, not just their name”, and that they should ask online platforms and social networks to take down dupes that cross the line. The retail sector’s recent run of lookalike disputes includes B&M’s High Court copyright claim against Morrisons, filed earlier this month.

Dispute Product Legal basis Outcome
Charlotte Tilbury v Aldi Filmstar Bronze & Glow palette design Copyright Successful for Charlotte Tilbury, per the Guardian
M&S v Aldi (Colin the Caterpillar) Cuthbert caterpillar cake Trade mark Settled in 2022 on confidential terms
M&S v Aldi (light-up gin bottle) Christmas gin liqueur bottle Registered designs M&S won; Aldi’s appeal dismissed in 2024
Lidl v Tesco Clubcard Prices logo Trade mark and passing off Lidl won; upheld by the Court of Appeal in 2024
Thatchers v Aldi Cloudy lemon cider can Trade mark Thatchers won on appeal in 2025

The pattern in these cases is that a similar product is rarely the problem on its own. Courts look at whether the overall presentation takes unfair advantage of a well-known brand or is likely to confuse shoppers, which is why packaging, colours and shapes feature so heavily in the claims.

What are your rights when you buy a dupe online?

UK consumer law does not have a lower standard for cheap goods. Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, goods bought from a trader must be of satisfactory quality, fit for purpose and as described, and what counts as satisfactory takes account of the price paid. A £50 jumper is not expected to match a £300 one, but it must match its own description, including any claim about fibre content such as “100% Mongolian cashmere”.

If an item is faulty, you have a 30-day short-term right to reject it for a full refund. After that the retailer can repair or replace it first, and for the first six months it is generally for the retailer to show that a fault was not there at delivery. Online purchases also carry a separate right under the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013 to cancel within 14 days of delivery for any reason, then a further 14 days to send the goods back.

How Quince’s policy compares with the law

Quince’s UK site advertises free standard delivery on all products and returns “for 365 days”. Its terms, read on 15 November, set conditions that sit on top of your statutory rights. The table below compares the two.

Issue Statutory minimum (online order) Quince UK policy
Change of mind Cancel within 14 days of delivery, then 14 days to return Return within 365 days of delivery for refund or exchange
Condition for change-of-mind returns Buyer can be charged for loss of value from handling beyond what is needed to inspect it Unworn, unwashed, unaltered, with all tags and packaging; photos may be requested
Refund timing Within 14 days of the retailer receiving goods back Within 14 days for statutory cancellations; up to 15 further business days under the extended policy
Refund method Original payment method Original method within provider limits, otherwise store credit
Faulty goods 30-day right to reject, then repair, replacement or refund Not separately set out in the returns FAQ
Return postage Retailer must say if the buyer pays Prepaid label issued on request

Quince also lists “final sale” items, which it says are perishable goods, certain hygiene items and customisable items. It states that these become non-returnable outside the 14-day statutory cancellation period, and says final sale status is shown near the price and at checkout. Underwear must be tried on over your own underwear and returned with tags.

Paying with Klarna, Clearpay or PayPal

One detail is easy to miss. Quince says refunds can only go back to the original payment method within each provider’s own time limit, and it lists PayPal, Klarna and Revolut Pay at 180 days and Clearpay at 120 days. A return made after that window is refunded as store credit instead, so a shopper who pays by Clearpay and sends a jumper back in month five would not get cash back under the extended policy.

Payment method also affects your fallback protection. Section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 makes a credit card provider jointly liable for a single item costing more than £100 and up to £30,000, which covers a £110 cashmere jumper but not a £60 one. Below £100, or on a debit card, the chargeback scheme run by the card networks is the usual route if a retailer will not refund.

Gift buyers should note that Quince does accept returns of gifts. Where the order was set up as a gift and the recipient received the delivery emails, the recipient can start a return from their own account; otherwise Quince asks for the order number or the giver’s email address. Retailers’ Christmas returns windows vary widely, so check the terms before buying a present that may need to be swapped.

Where does a Quince order ship from, and will you pay import charges?

Quince’s UK FAQ says it is “a global platform, connecting customers with manufacturers from across the world” and that an order “could ship from a variety of locations depending on the manufacturer’s location”. It currently ships to the UK, Canada and the United States. Delivery estimates are shown at checkout once an address is entered, and made-to-order items carry longer lead times.

Prices on the UK site are shown with VAT included, and the illustrative cost model reported by TheIndustry.fashion includes a line for duties, taxes and fees. That suggests the company prices import costs into the basket rather than leaving them for the courier to collect, but shoppers ordering larger items should check the final checkout total and the delivery terms before paying.

Why the import model matters to UK retailers

Direct-from-factory shipping is the same broad model used by marketplaces such as Shein and Temu, and it is under scrutiny. UK retailers have long argued that low-value import rules favour overseas sellers, and the government has been tightening how online platforms account for VAT, as set out in our report on the Budget plan to make Amazon and eBay collect sellers’ VAT. Quince positions itself at the quality end of the market, but its cost advantage depends on the same supply chain logic.

What does the dupe boom mean for UK brands and retailers?

For the brands being copied, the challenge is to show that the extra cost buys something real. Charlotte Tilbury, whose business is now owned by the Spanish group Puig, told the BBC that “when you dupe, you dupe the consumer”, and said of cheaper imitations: “If I could do them for those prices I would.” Savvy Marketing’s Shuttleworth told the Guardian that premium brands “need to be able to convince shoppers the quality difference is always worth paying for”.

For British fashion retailers named in Quince’s comparisons, the threat is less about copying and more about price perception. A shopper who sees a £199 Whistles jumper set beside a £100 alternative is invited to question the original price, even if the two garments differ in yarn grade, finish or design. Quince’s Laurent Duray, head of international, told TheIndustry.fashion that none of the companies already operating in the UK could “match the breadth of our catalogue, the quality and price point”, a direct challenge to the British mid-market.

The legal route for smaller brands

Large brands can afford High Court litigation, but smaller UK businesses face a harder calculation. The costs of protecting a name or product design are covered in our report on Gymshark’s attempt to cancel a small gym’s trade mark, which sets out UK Intellectual Property Office fees and timescales. Breheny’s advice to the Guardian, to protect packaging and get-up as well as the name, applies most strongly to independents whose products are copied on social media.

The high street’s own dupes

UK supermarkets and discounters are themselves among the biggest dupe sellers. Aldi’s candles, Lacura perfumes and beauty lines, Zara’s fragrances and M&S’s Aura Ambrette all appear in the dupe lists the Guardian cited. That makes the trend a transfer of spending within UK retail rather than simply a loss for it, with discounters and own-label ranges taking money that might otherwise have gone to premium brands and department stores.

What comes next for the dupe market

Quince has said its UK range will start narrower than its North American catalogue and expand quickly, with fashion and home textiles adapted to UK habits and weather. Its Christmas campaign is running across the UK now, which makes the next few weeks the first real test of whether British shoppers buy into the model at scale.

For the wider market, the next markers are the Christmas trading updates due in January, when retailers report how premium and value ranges performed, and any new lookalike litigation from brand owners. If dupes continue to win the gift budget, the pressure will fall most heavily on mid-market fashion and home brands whose prices sit between Aldi and true luxury.

How can you judge a dupe before you buy?

A dupe can be good value, but the risk is that similar packaging promises more than the product delivers. Breheny told the Guardian that “similar packaging doesn’t guarantee similar quality, ingredients or performance”, while adding that “a cheaper alternative isn’t necessarily always going to be inferior”. These checks help separate the two.

  1. Read the composition, not the comparison. For clothing, check the fibre content and weight on the product page; for candles, the wax type and burn time; for perfume, the concentration, such as eau de parfum or eau de toilette.
  2. Treat named comparisons as claims. A “compare at” price beside another brand’s product is the seller’s own judgement. Look for independent reviews that compare the two side by side.
  3. Check who the seller is. Buying from a UK-facing retailer with a UK returns process is very different from buying from an anonymous marketplace seller. If the listing uses the original brand’s name or logo, it is not a dupe.
  4. Check the returns window and the refund method. Note any final sale exclusions and whether a late return goes back as cash or store credit.
  5. Keep the evidence. Save screenshots of the description, especially fibre content and size claims, in case you need to rely on your Consumer Rights Act rights later.
  6. Be careful with cosmetics and skincare. Products applied to the skin carry the most risk if they are counterfeit rather than a genuine dupe, so buy from retailers you can trace.

When the gift is for someone else

For presents, the practical question is how easily the recipient can swap or return the item. Ask for a gift receipt, check whether the retailer allows the recipient to start the return, and remember that statutory rights for faulty goods belong to the buyer, so the giver may need to make the claim.

Frequently asked questions

What is a dupe?

A dupe is a cheaper product designed to offer a similar look, scent or feel to a well-known luxury item without claiming to be that item. It is sold under its own brand name, unlike a counterfeit, which pretends to be the genuine product.

Is it illegal to buy a dupe in the UK?

No. Buying a dupe for your own use is lawful. Legal risk sits with the seller if the product copies a brand’s trade mark, packaging, design or artwork too closely. Counterfeits that use another brand’s trade mark are illegal to make and sell.

Is Quince available in the UK?

Yes. Quince launched a UK website in October 2026, its first market outside North America, selling womenswear, menswear, children’s clothing and homeware priced in pounds with VAT included. It sells online only and has said it has no plans for UK shops.

Does Quince charge for UK delivery or returns?

Quince’s UK site says standard delivery is free on all products and that items can be returned within 365 days of delivery, with a prepaid returns label. Items must be unworn, unwashed and returned with tags and packaging, and some final sale items are excluded after the 14-day statutory cancellation period.

Will I get my money back if I return a Quince item late?

Not always as cash. Quince says refunds go to the original payment method only within the provider’s time limit, which it lists as 180 days for PayPal, Klarna and Revolut Pay and 120 days for Clearpay. Returns after that are refunded as store credit.

How much is the Aldi White Company candle dupe?

Aldi’s Inclusion Candles returned to stores on 1 November 2026, priced at £5.99 for the small 660g candle, £12.99 for the rectangle candle and £24.99 for the 4.5kg XXL candle. The Guardian compared the XXL candle with a £95 White Company candle. They are sold in stores while stocks last.

Can I return a faulty cheap dupe?

Yes. The Consumer Rights Act 2015 applies whatever the price. Goods must be of satisfactory quality, fit for purpose and as described, and you have 30 days to reject faulty goods for a full refund. The price you paid is taken into account when judging what is satisfactory.

Are dupe perfumes safe?

Dupe perfumes sold by established UK retailers under their own brand must meet UK cosmetics safety rules in the same way as any other fragrance. The risk is higher with counterfeits sold through anonymous online listings, where Trading Standards has found harmful substances in fake beauty products.